CardRewardsEditorial disclosure: CardRewards.ai is an independent comparison service. Our analysis is based on publicly available card data and is reviewed regularly by our editorial team. Card issuers do not influence our rankings or content. Last updated: June 2026.
The MenardsĀ® BIG Card ($0/yr) is better for everyday value, while the The Platinum Card from American Express ($895/yr) is worth it for frequent travelers who can use its premium perks. Here's the full comparison.
American Express
Capital One
Annual Fee
Welcome Bonus
| Category | The Platinum Card from American Express | MenardsĀ® BIG Card |
|---|---|---|
| Flights | 5X | 1X |
| Menards | 1X | 2X |
Both cards win in 1 categories each ā it comes down to which categories matter most to you.
Flights
The Platinum Card from American Express earns 5X vs 1X
Menards
MenardsĀ® BIG Card earns 2X vs 1X
The The Platinum Card from American Express costs $895/yr ā that's $895 more than the MenardsĀ® BIG Card (no annual fee). To justify that gap, you need to extract at least $895 in annual value from the card's higher earn rates and benefits.
The The Platinum Card from American Express offers lounge access, Global Entry/TSA PreCheck credit. Whether that justifies the fee depends on how often you use these benefits.
Bottom line: The $895 gap is significant. Choose the The Platinum Card from American Express only if you spend heavily on flights and hotels and will use its premium benefits regularly ā otherwise the MenardsĀ® BIG Card delivers strong value at a fraction of the cost.
Choosing one card means missing out on these benefits from the other.
Choosing MenardsĀ® BIG Card means losing:
Get the The Platinum Card from American Express if you:
The MenardsĀ® BIG Card has a lower annual fee ($0 vs $895), making it the more accessible option.
The The Platinum Card from American Express justifies its higher fee with premium perks like lounge access.
Choose the MenardsĀ® BIG Card if you want solid rewards with a lower cost of entry. Choose the The Platinum Card from American Express if you travel frequently and can maximize its premium benefits.
Editorial disclosure: The analysis on this page is based on publicly available card data and is updated regularly. CardRewards.ai is an independent comparison service. Card issuers do not influence our rankings or editorial content. Last updated: June 2026.
The MenardsĀ® BIG Card ($0/yr) is better for everyday value, while the The Platinum Card from American Express ($895/yr) is worth it for frequent travelers who can use its premium perks. Here's the full comparison.
American Express
Capital One
Annual Fee
Welcome Bonus
| Category | The Platinum Card from American Express | MenardsĀ® BIG Card |
|---|---|---|
| Flights | 5X | 1X |
| Menards | 1X | 2X |
Both cards win in 1 categories each ā it comes down to which categories matter most to you.
Flights
The Platinum Card from American Express earns 5X vs 1X
Menards
MenardsĀ® BIG Card earns 2X vs 1X
The The Platinum Card from American Express costs $895/yr ā that's $895 more than the MenardsĀ® BIG Card (no annual fee). To justify that gap, you need to extract at least $895 in annual value from the card's higher earn rates and benefits.
The The Platinum Card from American Express offers lounge access, Global Entry/TSA PreCheck credit. Whether that justifies the fee depends on how often you use these benefits.
Bottom line: The $895 gap is significant. Choose the The Platinum Card from American Express only if you spend heavily on flights and hotels and will use its premium benefits regularly ā otherwise the MenardsĀ® BIG Card delivers strong value at a fraction of the cost.
Choosing one card means missing out on these benefits from the other.
Choosing MenardsĀ® BIG Card means losing:
Get the The Platinum Card from American Express if you:
The MenardsĀ® BIG Card has a lower annual fee ($0 vs $895), making it the more accessible option.
The The Platinum Card from American Express justifies its higher fee with premium perks like lounge access.
Choose the MenardsĀ® BIG Card if you want solid rewards with a lower cost of entry. Choose the The Platinum Card from American Express if you travel frequently and can maximize its premium benefits.
Editorial disclosure: The analysis on this page is based on publicly available card data and is updated regularly. CardRewards.ai is an independent comparison service. Card issuers do not influence our rankings or editorial content. Last updated: June 2026.
The MenardsĀ® BIG Card ($0/yr) is better for everyday value, while the The Platinum Card from American Express ($895/yr) is worth it for frequent travelers who can use its premium perks. Here's the full comparison.
American Express
Capital One
Annual Fee
Welcome Bonus
| Category | The Platinum Card from American Express | MenardsĀ® BIG Card |
|---|---|---|
| Flights | 5X | 1X |
| Menards | 1X | 2X |
Both cards win in 1 categories each ā it comes down to which categories matter most to you.
Flights
The Platinum Card from American Express earns 5X vs 1X
Menards
MenardsĀ® BIG Card earns 2X vs 1X
The The Platinum Card from American Express costs $895/yr ā that's $895 more than the MenardsĀ® BIG Card (no annual fee). To justify that gap, you need to extract at least $895 in annual value from the card's higher earn rates and benefits.
The The Platinum Card from American Express offers lounge access, Global Entry/TSA PreCheck credit. Whether that justifies the fee depends on how often you use these benefits.
Bottom line: The $895 gap is significant. Choose the The Platinum Card from American Express only if you spend heavily on flights and hotels and will use its premium benefits regularly ā otherwise the MenardsĀ® BIG Card delivers strong value at a fraction of the cost.
Choosing one card means missing out on these benefits from the other.
Choosing MenardsĀ® BIG Card means losing:
Get the The Platinum Card from American Express if you:
The MenardsĀ® BIG Card has a lower annual fee ($0 vs $895), making it the more accessible option.
The The Platinum Card from American Express justifies its higher fee with premium perks like lounge access.
Choose the MenardsĀ® BIG Card if you want solid rewards with a lower cost of entry. Choose the The Platinum Card from American Express if you travel frequently and can maximize its premium benefits.
Editorial disclosure: The analysis on this page is based on publicly available card data and is updated regularly. CardRewards.ai is an independent comparison service. Card issuers do not influence our rankings or editorial content. Last updated: June 2026.
| Hotels | 1X | 1X |
| Everything Else | 1X | 1X |
Network
Key Benefits
Pros
Cons
Get the MenardsĀ® BIG Card if you:
| Hotels | 1X | 1X |
| Everything Else | 1X | 1X |
Network
Key Benefits
Pros
Cons
Get the MenardsĀ® BIG Card if you:
| Hotels | 1X | 1X |
| Everything Else | 1X | 1X |
Network
Key Benefits
Pros
Cons
Get the MenardsĀ® BIG Card if you: